TN: Belated notes...
Hoopes 2005:
I really wanted to like this wine. Good press, nice folks etc. but it just did not deliver. Everything was there, good concentration, Oakville tell-tale fruit but no acid, no back-bone. What a shame, with some back-bone this would actually be a good wine. Porty, sloppy fruit.
Herman Story, Nots and Bolts 2006 Syrah
I have to agree with Josh Reynolds....how to achieve balance with that kind of force and alc. is beyond me. But the facts is not important. This is truly a great Syrah. Power and brute force packed into elegance, seamlessness, and an utterly terrific expression of Syrah in it´s raw nature. Some European alcohol "hunters" have something to learn about balance. Stellar wine.
Herman Story Grenache 2006
Not the Larner, but terrific nonetheless. Equally seamless, elegant, smooth and well-balanced. Delicious, and of course delivers well above it´s pricepoint. Russell From is a master on these varietals ?
Guigal D´Ampuis 98
Okay, I promise, this is my last bashing of this wine, as it´s thankfully my last bottle from a 12-case. Oaky in extremis, out of balance. A mess of a wine.
Montrose 1989
Great wine....might surpass the 90. Concentrated, garrique in check, clean and focused, neverending finish..
I really wanted to like this wine. Good press, nice folks etc. but it just did not deliver. Everything was there, good concentration, Oakville tell-tale fruit but no acid, no back-bone. What a shame, with some back-bone this would actually be a good wine. Porty, sloppy fruit.
Herman Story, Nots and Bolts 2006 Syrah
I have to agree with Josh Reynolds....how to achieve balance with that kind of force and alc. is beyond me. But the facts is not important. This is truly a great Syrah. Power and brute force packed into elegance, seamlessness, and an utterly terrific expression of Syrah in it´s raw nature. Some European alcohol "hunters" have something to learn about balance. Stellar wine.
Herman Story Grenache 2006
Not the Larner, but terrific nonetheless. Equally seamless, elegant, smooth and well-balanced. Delicious, and of course delivers well above it´s pricepoint. Russell From is a master on these varietals ?
Guigal D´Ampuis 98
Okay, I promise, this is my last bashing of this wine, as it´s thankfully my last bottle from a 12-case. Oaky in extremis, out of balance. A mess of a wine.
Montrose 1989
Great wine....might surpass the 90. Concentrated, garrique in check, clean and focused, neverending finish..




